Britain’s newly appointed Muslim Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, is under fire for her announcement to suspend visas for countries, including Pakistan, that refuse to accept failed asylum seekers.

Critics argue that her policy unfairly targets nations that contribute significantly to the UK workforce, including doctors, nurses, and students.

Observers warn that while the policy may pressure smaller, aid-dependent countries, it could ultimately harm Britain more, as noted by The Independent.

British readers have pointed out the irony of a Muslim politician, who is the daughter of immigrants, endorsing measures that could limit opportunities for individuals from South Asia and Africa.

A British-Pakistani analyst highlighted, “Pakistanis are among the largest communities in Britain. Cutting student and work visas would not only affect us, but also weaken the NHS, which relies on Pakistani and Indian doctors and nurses.”

Analysts also caution that such restrictions are unlikely to be effective against countries like Pakistan, India, or Bangladesh, which boast strong diaspora communities that play a vital role in the UK economy.

For Pakistan, the implications are significant, as the country sends thousands of students and healthcare workers to the UK annually.

Remittances from the Pakistani diaspora are crucial for stabilising the national economy, and any visa suspension would directly impact families dependent on this financial support.

Critics in the UK have labeled the move as “self-inflicted punishment,” emphasizing that limiting skilled migrants from Muslim and South Asian countries could jeopardize Britain’s healthcare and education systems.